Each month, the Certificate of Need Section makes decisions regarding applications under review to either conditionally approve the application or to disapprove it. The Certificate of Need Section also prepares "findings" which explain the basis for the decision.
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lincoln | F-012414-23 | Denver Surgery Center | 230716 | ASC | Develop no more than one GI endoscopy room and one procedure room at an existing ambulatory surgery center | 9/1/2023 | 12/8/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012431-23 | Novant Health Imaging Mt. Island Lake | 230804 | DXCTR | Develop a diagnostic center by acquiring no more than one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP, a CT scanner, x-ray, mammography, and ultrasound | 10/1/2023 | 12/21/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012429-23 | Matthews Radiation Oncology Center | 190631 | LINAC | Replace an existing LINAC | 10/1/2023 | 12/1/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Pitt | Q-012426-23 | ECU Health Medical Center | 933410 | HOSPITAL | Acquire and relocate no more than 16 inpatient rehabilitation beds from East Carolina Health-Heritage, Inc. | 10/1/2023 | 12/20/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Durham | J-012437-23 | Duke University Hospital | 943138 | HOSPITAL | Cost overrun for Project ID #J-11851-20 (acquire one unit of angiography equipment for an existing OR to create a hybrid OR) | 11/1/2023 | 11/20/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Gaston | F-012391-23 | CaroMont Regional Medical Center - Belmont | 190371 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 24 additional acute care beds pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 78 beds upon project completion | 7/1/2023 | 11/15/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Iredell | F-012423-23 | Vascular ASC | 230722 | ASC | Develop a new ASF with no more than one dedicated vascular access OR pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 9/1/2023 | 11/16/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Martin | Q-012427-23 | Dialysis Care of Martin County | 960043 | ESRD | Relocate no more than eight in-center dialysis stations from Robersonville Dialysis for a total of no more than 23 stations upon project completion | 10/1/2023 | 11/15/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012403-23 | Novant Health Ballantyne Medical Center | 180518 | HOSPITAL | Acquire a fixed MRI scanner pursuant to Policy TE-3 | 7/1/2023 | 11/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012389-23 | Interim HealthCare | 230533 | HC | Develop a new Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 11/21/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012394-23 | Healthview Home Health - New Hanover | 230540 | HC | Develop a new Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 11/21/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012401-23 | Aveanna Home Health-New Hanover | 230545 | HC | Develop a new Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 11/21/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012405-23 | Well Care Home Health of New Hanover | 230547 | HC | Develop a new Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 11/21/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012404-23 | BAYADA Home Health Care | 230548 | HC | Develop a new Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 11/21/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Pitt | Q-012392-23 | ECU Health Medical Center | 933410 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than two ORs pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination for a total of 36 ORs, including 4 dedicated C-Section ORs and 1 Trauma OR | 7/1/2023 | 11/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Pitt | Q-012421-23 | Greenville MRI, LLC | 030544 | DXCTR | Develop no more than one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 9/1/2023 | 11/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Pitt | Q-012397-23 | Eastern Nephrology Associates ASC | 230544 | ASC | Develop a new ASC with no more than one single specialty dedicated vascular OR pursuant to 2023 SMFP need determination and three procedure rooms | 7/1/2023 | 11/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012393-23 | Raleigh Radiology Knightdale | 190281 | DXCTR | Acquire a fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 11/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012396-23 | Wake Radiology Cary | 001330 | DXCTR | Acquire a fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 11/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012395-23 | Duke Imaging Garner | 230129 | DXCTR | Acquire a fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 11/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012399-23 | WakeMed North Hospital | 990974 | HOSPITAL | Acquire a fixed MRI scanner pursuant to Policy TE-3 | 7/1/2023 | 11/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buncombe | B-012388-23 | The Endoscopy Center | 943487 | ASC | Relocate the facility and develop three new GI endoscopy rooms for a total of no more than eight GI endoscopy rooms upon project completion | 6/1/2023 | 10/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Forsyth | G-012420-23 | Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center | 943495 | HOSPITAL | Cost overrun for Project ID# G-8460-10 (Construction of a new building to include 8 operating rooms, two procedure rooms, and related clinical space pursuant to Policy AC-3) | 9/1/2023 | 10/31/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Gaston | F-012409-23 | Fresenius Kidney Care North Gaston | 160496 | ESRD | Add no more than 1 dialysis station pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 17 stations upon project completion | 8/1/2023 | 10/10/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Hoke | N-012407-23 | Dialysis Care of Hoke County | 945165 | ESRD | Add no more than 3 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 28 stations upon project completion | 8/1/2023 | 10/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012408-23 | BMA West Charlotte | 955792 | ESRD | Add no more than 2 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 31 stations upon project completion | 8/1/2023 | 10/12/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Onslow | P-012411-23 | The Landings at Topsail Shores | 230628 | ACH | Develop a new 40-bed ACH facility by relocating no more than 40 ACH beds from Onslow House | 8/1/2023 | 10/26/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alamance | G-012365-23 | Alliance Healthcare Services Mobile MRI 2023 | 230323 | Major Med Equip | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Buncombe | B-012380-23 | Mission Hospital-Mission FSER West | 230341 | HOSPITAL | Develop a freestanding ED in western Buncombe County licensed under Mission Hospital | 5/1/2023 | 9/25/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Cabarrus | F-012367-23 | Atrium Health Cabarrus | 943049 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 65 acute care beds pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 514 acute care beds upon completion of this project and Project ID #F-12116-21 (add 22 beds) | 5/1/2023 | 9/13/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Caldwell | E-012398-23 | EmergeOrtho-Lenoir | 230543 | DXCTR | Acquire a fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Durham | J-012357-23 | EmergeOrtho Mobile MRI Blue Ridge/Foothills Route | 230317 | OTHER | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Durham | J-012358-23 | EmergeOrtho Mobile MRI Triad Route | 230319 | OTHER | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Durham | J-012359-23 | EmergeOrtho Mobile MRI Triangle Route | 230320 | OTHER | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Durham | J-012377-23 | Duke North Pavilion | 956937 | HOSPITAL | COR for Project ID # J-11613-18 (renovate and upfit space in North Pavilion for hospital services) | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Durham | J-012378-23 | Duke Imaging Mobile MRI | 230334 | DXCTR | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Durham | J-012406-23 | Durham Regional Dialysis | 160396 | ESRD | Add no more than 10 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 1 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 20 stations upon project completion | 8/1/2023 | 9/11/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Forsyth | G-012356-23 | PHC Home Health-Forsyth | 230318 | HC | Develop a new Medicaire-certified home health agency pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/20/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Forsyth | G-012362-23 | Well Care Home Health of Forsyth County | 230321 | HC | Develop a new Medicare-Certified Home Health Agency | 5/1/2023 | 9/20/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Forsyth | G-012364-23 | Novant Health Home Care-Forsyth | 230322 | HC | Develop a new Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/20/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Forsyth | G-012369-23 | Aveanna Home Health - Forsyth | 230327 | HC | Develop a new Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/20/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Gaston | F-012390-23 | CaroMont Regional Medical Center | 943184 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 24 additional acute care beds pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 423 beds upon completion of this project, Project ID# F-11749-19 (develop a new hospital by relocating no more than 21 acute care beds from CRMC and developing 33 acute care beds pursuant to the need determination in the 2019 SMFP, and Project ID# F-11894-20 (add 64 acute care beds pursuant to the need determination in the 2020 SMFP | 7/1/2023 | 9/19/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Guilford | G-012372-23 | Novant Health-Norfolk, LLC (1) | 230325 | DXCTR | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Guilford | G-012373-23 | Novant Health-Norfolk, LLC (2) | 230326 | DXCTR | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Johnston | J-012400-23 | Johnston Health | 943290 | HOSPITAL | Acquire one additional unit of fixed cardiac catheterization equipment pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 7/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012381-23 | Carolina Neurosurgery & Spine (2) | 230333 | DXCTR | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012368-23 | Carolina Neurosurgery & Spine (1) | 230328 | DXCTR | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 6/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Moore | H-012360-23 | Southern Pines Surgery Center | 220730 | ASC | Develop a new ASF by relocating two existing ORs from Surgery Center of Pinehurst and developing two procedure rooms | 5/1/2023 | 9/22/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012353-23 | Delaney Radiologist Group | 030359 | DXCTR | Acquire one fixed MRI scanner pursuant the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012361-23 | Novant Health New Hanover Regional Medical Center | 943372 | HOSPITAL | Acquire one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012370-23 | Wilmington Health at Porters Neck-8090 Market Street | 230324 | Major Med Equip | Acquire one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012374-23 | EmergeOrtho- Wilmington Porters Neck | 230344 | DXCTR | Acquire one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Orange | J-012386-23 | Carolina Dialysis-Carrboro | 956088 | ESRD | Relocate no more than 2 dialysis stations from Carolina Dialysis Siler City, no more than 2 dialysis stations from FMC Dialysis Center West Pettigrew, and no more than 1 dialysis station from Carolina Dialysis Pittsboro for a total of no more than 46 stations upon completion of this project, Project ID #J-12080-21 (relocate 2 stations), and Project ID #J-11995-20 (relocate 2 stations) | 6/1/2023 | 9/15/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012402-23 | Wake Radiology UNC REX PET CT-Imaging Center | 230546 | DXCTR | Develop a new diagnostic center by acquiring, replacing, and relocating an existing fixed PET scanner | 7/1/2023 | 9/28/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012354-23 | Liberty Commons Nursing & Rehabilitation Center of Wake County | 230316 | NH | Develop a new 125-bed NF by relocating 19 NF beds from Liberty Commons of Alamance, 28 NF beds from Cross Creek (Hyde County), 20 NF beds from Oak Forest (Forsyth County), and 58 NF beds from Golden Years (Cumberland County) | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012355-23 | Liberty Commons Rehabilitation and Nursing Care of Raleigh | 230315 | NH | Develop a new 125-bed NF by relocating 122 NF beds from Liberty Commons of Carteret County (Project ID # P-12179-22 (Develop a new facility by relocating no more than 122 NF beds from Harborview Health Care Center)) and 3 NF beds from Pinehurst Healthcare and Rehabilitation (Moore County) | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012371-23 | UNC REX Hospital | 953429 | HOSPITAL | Acquire one linear accelerator pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012375-23 | PHSNC Mobile MRI Scanner | 230330 | DXCTR | Acquire one mobile MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012376-23 | WakeMed Raleigh Medical Park | 090441 | DXCTR | Acquire one linear accelerator pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012379-23 | Duke Radiation Oncology Garner | 230343 | HOSPITAL | Acquire one linear accelerator pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/2023 | 9/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brunswick | O-012343-23 | Leland Dialysis | 140237 | ESRD | Add no more than 7 in-center dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of 23 in-center stations upon project completion | 4/1/23 | 8/25/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Buncombe | B-012363-23 | The Laurels of Summit Ridge | 923279 | NH | Cost Overrun for Project ID #B-12182-22 (Relocate no more than 8 NF beds from the Laurels of GreenTree Ridge for a total of no more than 68 NF beds and 23 ACH beds upon completion of this project and Project ID# B-11270-16 (relocate 29 ACH beds)) | 5/1/23 | 8/8/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Catawba | E-012410-23 | Fresenius Kidney Care Newton | 160340 | ESRD | Add no more than 2 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 17 stations upon project completion | 8/1/23 | 8/23/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Johnston | J-012349-23 | Fresenius Kidney Care West Johnston | 170520 | ESRD | Add no more than 3 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 1 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 15 stations upon completion of this project and Project ID# J-11739-19 (relocate 2 stations) | 4/1/23 | 8/22/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012387-23 | Charlotte Gastroenterology & Hepatology - Ballantyne | 070703 | ASC | Relocate the facility and develop no more than three new GI endoscopy rooms for a total of no more than five GI endoscopy rooms upon project completion | 6/1/23 | 8/29/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Stanly | F-012366-23 | Atrium Health Imaging Locust | 040560 | DXCTR | Acquire one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/23 | 8/9/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012383-23 | Britthaven of Holly Springs | 101149 | NH | COS/COR for Project ID# J-12123-21 (Cost overrun for Project ID# J-8618-10 (Develop a new 90-bed nursing facility)) to relocate 30 NF beds from Enfield Oaks Nursing and Rehabilitation Center (Halifax County) for a total of 120 NF beds upon project completion | 5/1/23 | 8/31/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012382-23 | Wake County Health & Rehab Center | 110707 | NH | COS and COR (Project ID# J-8713-11) relocate 25 NF beds from Enfield Oaks Nursing and Rehabilitation Center (Halifax County) for a total of no more than 120 NF beds upon project completion | 5/1/23 | 8/22/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012385-23 | Raleigh Endoscopy Center | 923422 | ASC | Relocate the facility and develop no more than two new GI endoscopy rooms for a total of no more than six GI endoscopy rooms upon project completion | 6/1/23 | 8/9/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brunswick | O-012316-23 | Novant Health Home Care-Brunswick | 230123 | HC | Develop a Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 3/1/23 | 7/25/23 | Denied | Findings |
| Brunswick | O-012318-23 | 3HC-Brunswick | 230125 | HC | Develop a Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 3/1/23 | 7/25/23 | Denied | Findings |
| Brunswick | O-012324-23 | BAYADA Home Health Care, Inc. | 230126 | HC | Develop a Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 3/1/23 | 7/25/23 | Denied | Findings |
| Brunswick | O-012334-23 | Well Care Home Health of Brunswick County | 230131 | HC | Develop a Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 3/1/23 | 7/25/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Brunswick | O-012336-23 | Healthview Home Health - Brunswick | 230132 | HC | Develop a Medicare-certified home health agency pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 3/1/23 | 7/25/23 | Denied | Findings |
| Buncombe | B-012335-23 | Mission Hospital | 943349 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than one PET/CT scanner pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP for a total of no more than two PET scanners upon project completion | 3/1/23 | 7/26/23 | Denied | Findings |
| Cabarrus | F-012315-23 | Carolina Digestive Endoscopy Center-Concord | 230124 | ASC | Develop a new ASF with no more than one GI endoscopy room | 3/1/23 | 7/3/23 | Denied | Findings |
| Carteret | P-012323-23 | PruittHealth-SeaLevel | 923448 | NH | Change of scope and cost overrun for Project ID #P-11541-18 (relocate 104 NF beds to a new replacement facility) | 3/1/23 | 7/26/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Cleveland | C-012337-23 | Peak Resources-Shelby | 923377 | NH | Develop a replacement nursing facility by relocating no more than 100 nursing facility beds | 3/1/23 | 7/3/23 | Denied | Findings |
| Duplin | P-012327-23 | ECU Health Duplin Hospital | 923139 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than one fixed MRI scanner pursuant the need determination in 2023 SMFP | 3/1/23 | 7/18/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Guilford | G-012352-23 | CK Vascular Center | 230309 | ASC | Develop one dedicated vascular access OR for HSA II pursuant to the 2023 SMFP need determination | 5/1/23 | 7/28/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Guilford | G-012330-23 | Greensboro Medical Center | 230130 | HOSPITAL | Develop a new hospital by relocating no more than 36 acute care beds and two operating rooms from High Point Medical Center | 3/1/23 | 7/26/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Guilford | G-012351-23 | BMA of Southwest Greensboro | 991046 | ESRD | Add no more than 2 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 35 stations upon completion of this project, Project ID# G-12161-21 (add 8 stations) and Project ID# G-12130-21 (relocate 8 stations) | 4/1/23 | 7/18/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Henderson | B-012331-23 | AdventHealth Hendersonville | 943388 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than one fixed PET scanner pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 3/1/23 | 7/26/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012319-23 | Atrium Health Lake Norman | 190513 | HOSPITAL | Cost overrun for Project ID# F-12010-20 (develop a new acute care hospital) | 3/1/23 | 7/3/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Robeson | N-012344-23 | Maxton Dialysis Center | 140144 | ESRD | Add no more than 3 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of facility need methodology for a total of no more than 17 stations upon project completion | 4/1/23 | 7/28/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012314-23 | The Cardinal at North Hills | 080413 | NH | Develop no more than 10 nursing facility beds for a total of no more than 25 nursing facility beds upon project completion | 3/1/23 | 7/28/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012384-23 | Triangle Health and Rehabilitation Center | 230342 | NH | Develop a new 120-bed NF by relocating 30 NF beds from Bethany Woods Nursing and Rehabilitation (Stanly County), 5 NF beds from Enfield Oaks Nursing and Rehabilitation Center (Halifax County), 9 NF beds from Harmony Hall Nursing and Rehabilitation Center (Lenoir County), 10 NF beds from Maple Grove Health and Rehabilitation Center (Guilford County), 12 NF beds from Pine Ridge Health and Rehabilitation Center in (Davidson County), 20 NF beds from University Place Nursing and Rehabilitation Center (Mecklenburg County), 20 NF beds from Westwood Hills Nursing and Rehabilitation center (Wilkes County), and 14 NF beds from Willow Creek Nursing and Rehabilitation Center (Wayne County) | 5/1/23 | 7/21/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Caldwell | E-012348-23 | BMA Lenoir | 170328 | ESRD | Add no more than 4 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodoloyg for a total of no more than 54 stations upon project completion | 4/1/23 | 6/15/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Cumberland | M-012332-23 | Cape Fear Valley Medical Center | 943057 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 18 acute care beds pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP for a total of no more than 636 beds upon project completion, including 44 neonatal intensive care units (NICU) beds, upon completion of this project, Project ID# M-12178-22 (add 29 AC beds pursuant to a 2022 SMFP Need Determination) and Project ID# M-8689-11 (add 65 AC beds pursuant to a 2011 Need Determination). | 3/1/23 | 6/29/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Duplin | P-012326-23 | The Gardens of Rose Hill | 945023 | ACH | Relocate no more 15 ACH beds from Autumn Village to The Gardens of Rose Hill for a total of no more than 60 ACH beds upon project completion | 3/1/23 | 6/22/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Durham | J-012350-23 | FMC Dialysis Services of Briggs Avenue | 990969 | ESRD | Add no more than 5 dialysis stations pursuant to the Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 29 stations upon completion of this project and Project ID# J-12311-23 (relocate 5 stations) | 4/1/23 | 6/23/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Forsyth | G-012341-23 | The Atrium/The Respite Center | 922007 | MHL | Construct two six-bed ICF-IID group homes on the same site by relocating 10 beds from The Arches in Winston-Salem and two beds from The Atrium/The Respite Center | 4/1/23 | 6/26/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Forsyth | G-012338-23 | Harmony at Kernersville | 230135 | ACH | Develop a new ACH facility by relocating 90 ACH beds from The Ivy at Clemmons, including 36 SCU beds | 3/1/23 | 6/23/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Guilford | G-012347-23 | BMA of South Greensboro | 980838 | ESRD | Add no more than 4 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 58 stations upon completion of this project and Project ID# G-11737-19 (relocate 10 stations) | 4/1/23 | 6/26/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Jackson | A-012313-23 | Balsam Home Training | 230039 | ESRD | Develop a new freestanding home dialysis training facility by relocating no more than 2 existing dialysis stations from Sylva Dialysis dedicated exclusively to home hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis training and support | 2/1/23 | 6/2/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Nash | L-012346-23 | Rocky Mount Kidney Center | 944658 | ESRD | Add no more than 1 dialysis station pursuant to Condition 2 for a total of no more than 51 stations upon completion of this project and Project ID# L-12165-21 (add 10 stations) | 4/1/23 | 6/19/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012317-23 | Novant Health New Hanover Regional Medical Center | 943372 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 25 acute care beds pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP for a total of no more than 774 acute care beds, including NICU beds, at all campuses of Novant Health New Hanover Regional Medical Center upon completion of this project, Project ID# O-11947-20 (develop a new satellite hospital campus including 36 new acute care beds) and Project ID# O-12081-21 (develop 35 new acute care beds) | 3/1/23 | 6/30/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Rutherford | C-012345-23 | Dialysis Care of Rutherford County | 955824 | ESRD | Add no more than one in-center station pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 31 in-center stations upon project completion | 4/1/23 | 6/15/23 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Durham | J-012311-23 | Fresenius Kidney Care Eno River | 170324 | ESRD | Relocate no more than 5 dialysis stations from FMC Briggs Avenue for a total of no more than 19 dialysis stations upon project completion | 2/1/2023 | 5/1/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Randolph | G-012339-23 | Cone Health Cancer Center - Asheboro | 230134 | DXCTR | Replace and relocate no more than one linear accelerator and no more than one CT simulator to a new cancer center | 3/1/2023 | 5/24/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012329-23 | Duke Raleigh Hospital | 923421 | HOSPITAL | Acquire no more than one CT scanner for a total of no more than five CT scanners | 3/1/2023 | 5/26/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012321-23 | Raleigh Endoscopy Center-Holly Springs | 230128 | ASC | Develop a new ASF with no more than three GI endoscopy rooms upon project completion | 3/1/2023 | 5/22/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012328-23 | Duke Imaging Garner | 230129 | DXCTR | Develop a diagnostic center with mammography and ultrasound | 3/1/2023 | 5/5/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alamance | G-012301-22 | Carolina Dialysis - Mebane | 100545 | ESRD | Add no more than 2 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 27 dialysis stations upon completion of this project and Project ID# J-12080-21 (relocate 2 stations) | 12/1/2022 | 4/19/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Brunswick | O-012325-23 | Novant Health Brunswick Medical Center | 061342 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP for a total of no more than two fixed MRI scanners upon project completion | 3/1/2023 | 4/26/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Cumberland | M-012333-23 | Cape Fear Valley Medical Center | 943057 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 8 hospice inpatient beds pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 3/1/2023 | 4/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012304-22 | Wilmington Health on Silver Stream Lane | 220781 | ASC | Develop a new ASF by relocating no more than three existing multispecialty GI endoscopy rooms and adding one new GI endoscopy room for a total of no more than four GI endoscopy rooms | 12/1/2022 | 4/28/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Orange | J-012320-23 | University of North Carolina Medical Center | 923517 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 24 Level IV NICU beds for a total of no more than 82 neonatal beds, including 72 Level IV NICU beds and 10 Level III neonatal beds | 3/1/2023 | 4/28/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Orange | J-012322-23 | University of North Carolina Hospitals-Hillsborough | 090274 | HOSPITAL | Acquire no more than one unit of fixed cardiac catherization equipment pursuant to the need determination in the 2023 SMFP | 3/1/2023 | 4/28/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Randolph | G-012307-23 | Randolph Hospital | 933425 | HOSPITAL | Develop an inpatient dialysis service with no more than 3 stations | 2/1/2023 | 4/6/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Swain | A-012312-23 | Cherokee Dialysis Center | 970527 | ESRD | Relocate existing dialysis facility | 2/1/2023 | 4/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beaufort | Q-012310-23 | Beaufort County Home | 230038 | ESRD | Develop a new freestanding home dialysis training facility by relocating no more than two dialysis stations and the entire home training program from FMC Pamlico to be exclusively dedicated to home hemodialysis and peritoneal dialysis training and support services | 2/1/2023 | 3/22/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Edgecombe | l-012298-22 | FMC Tarboro | 150155 | ESRD | Add no more than one dialysis station pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 19 dialysis stations upon completion of this project and Project ID# L-12103-21 (add 4 stations) | 12/1/2022 | 3/17/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Guilford | G-012289-22 | The Stanbridge | 220735 | ACH | Develop a new ACH by relocating no more than 60 ACH beds, including 32 SCU beds, from Holden Heights | 11/1/2022 | 3/28/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Guilford | G-012288-22 | The Waverly at Oak Hollow | 200746 | ACH | Relocate no more than 25 ACH beds from Holden Heights to The Waverly Oak Hollow which is a change of scope to Project ID# G-11965-20 (relocate 29 ACH beds from Guilford House and 11 ACH beds from Holden Heights) for a total of no more than 65 ACH beds | 11/1/2022 | 3/23/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012285-22 | Novant Health Matthews Medical Center | 945076 | HOSPITAL | Acquire no more than 1 fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 2 fixed MRI scanners | 11/1/2022 | 3/28/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012287-22 | OrthoCarolina University | 220734 | DXCTR | Acquire no more than 1 fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination | 11/1/2022 | 3/28/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012280-22 | Atrium Health Pineville | 110878 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 5 acute care beds pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 308 acute care beds upon completion of this project, Project ID #F-12084-21 (relocate 26 beds to Atrium Health Steele Creek), and Project ID #F-12147-21 (develop 25 beds) | 11/1/2022 | 3/24/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012281-22 | Carolinas Medical Center | 943070 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 38 acute care beds pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 1,255 acute care beds upon completion of this project, Project ID #F-12006-20 (add 87 beds), and Project ID #F-12149-21 (add 75 beds) | 11/1/2022 | 3/24/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012282-22 | Atrium Health University City | 923516 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 8 acute care beds pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 120 acute care beds upon completion of this project and Project ID #F-12146-21 (add 8 beds) | 11/1/2022 | 3/24/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012293-22 | Novant Health Presbyterian Medical Center | 943501 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 30 acute care beds pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 542 acute care beds upon completion of this project, Project ID #F-8765-11 (add 14 beds), Project ID #F-11625-18 (relocate 36 beds to develop Novant Health Ballantyne Medical Center), and Project ID #F-12144-21 (add 15 beds) | 11/1/2022 | 3/24/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Moore | H-012284-22 | Southern Pines Surgery Center | 220730 | ASC | Acquire and relocate no more than two ORs from Surgery Center of Pinehurst to develop a new ASC with four procedure rooms | 11/1/2022 | 3/29/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Moore | H-012290-22 | Sandhills Health & Rehabilitation, LLC | 220736 | NH | Develop a new NF by relocating no more than 86 NF beds from St. Joseph of the Pines | 11/1/2022 | 3/22/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| New Hanover | O-012295-22 | The Luminance at Riverlights | 160565 | ACH | Relocate no more than 20 ACH beds from Castle Creek Memory Care to The Luminance at Riverlights which is a change of scope to Project ID# O-11964-20 (relocate 40 ACH beds from New Hanover House) for a total of no more than 60 ACH beds | 11/1/2022 | 3/28/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Pitt | Q-012294-22 | Greenville MRI, LLC | 030544 | DXCTR | Acquire no more than one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination for a total of no more than 3 fixed MRI scanners upon project completion | 11/1/2022 | 3/29/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Pitt | Q-012286-22 | Orthopaedics East & Sports Medicine Center | 220733 | DXCTR | Acquire no more than one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination | 11/1/2022 | 3/29/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Pitt | Q-012297-22 | FMC Dialysis Services East Carolina University | 960406 | ESRD | Relocate the entire facility and add no more than six dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 47 stations upon project completion | 12/1/2022 | 3/3/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alexander | E-012300-22 | Fresenius Medical Care of Alexander County | 090725 | ESRD | Add no more than 5 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 18 dialysis stations upon project completion | 12/1/2022 | 2/24/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Burke | E-012305-22 | UNC Health Blue Ridge | 943191 | HOSPITAL | Add no more than one GI endoscopy room at the Morganton campus for no more than two GI endoscopy rooms | 12/1/2022 | 2/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Craven | P-012306-22 | CCHC Endoscopy Center | 061311 | ASC | Add no more than one GI endoscopy room for a total of no more than four GI endoscopy rooms upon project completion | 12/1/2022 | 2/20/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Cumberland | M-012270-22 | Cape Fear Valley Medical Center | 943057 | HOSPITAL | Develop a hospital based outpatient 4-station dialysis facility pursuant to Policy ESRD-3 | 10/1/2022 | 2/24/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Currituck | R-012271-22 | Sentara Advanced Imaging Solutions-Moyock | 220669 | DXCTR | Develop one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination | 10/1/2022 | 2/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Edgecombe | L-012277-22 | FMC Tarboro | 150155 | ESRD | Cost overrun for Project ID# L-12103-21 (add 4 dialysis stations for a total of 18) | 11/1/2022 | 2/17/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Pasquotank | R-012266-22 | Chesapeake Regional Imaging Centers-Elizabeth City | 220668 | DXCTR | Develop one fixed MRI scanner pursuant to the 2022 SMFP need determination | 10/1/2022 | 2/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Pitt | Q-012302-22 | Carolinas Endoscopy Center | 061341 | ASC | Add no more than one GI endoscopy room for no more than four GI endoscopy rooms upon project completion | 12/1/2022 | 2/24/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| County | Project ID | Facility | FID | Facility Type | Project Description | Application Review Date | Decision Date | Decision | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chatham | J-012246-22 | Chatham County Rehabilitation Center | 130367 | NH | Change of Scope and Cost Overrun for Project ID # J-11656-19 (Relocate no more 6 ACH beds from Liberty Commons Nursing and Rehab Center of Halifax County and no more than 30 ACH beds from Cross Creek Healthcare of Hyde County for a total of no more than 105 NF beds and 36 ACH beds upon project completion) | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Chowan | R-012268-22 | Chowan Home Dialysis | 200027 | ESRD | Develop one dialysis station to be used exclusively for home hemodialysis training and support services | 10/1/2022 | 1/25/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Gaston | F-012299-22 | Fresenius Medical Care Belmont | 050039 | ESRD | Add no more than 9 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 2 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 28 dialysis stations upon project completion | 12/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Iredell | F-012267-22 | Iredell Memorial Hospital, Incorporated | 933284 | HOSPITAL | Develop a new facility with 4 stations pursuant to Policy ESRD-3 | 10/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Iredell | F-012283-22 | Lake Norman Radiation Oncology-Mooresville | 220729 | LINAC | Replace linear accelerator | 11/1/2022 | 1/25/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012303-22 | Brookshire Dialysis | 150477 | ESRD | Add no more than 9 dialysis stations pursuant to Condition 1 of the facility need methodology for a total of no more than 20 stations upon project completion | 12/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012257-22 | Atrium Health Pineville | 110878 | HOSPITAL | Acquire no more than one additional linear accelerator pursuant to the need determination in the 2022 SMFP for a total of no more than two linear accelerators | 9/1/2022 | 1/26/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012278-22 | Fresenius Kidney Care Regal Oaks | 150024 | ESRD | Cost overrun for Project ID# F-12162-21 (add 2 dialysis stations for a total of 21 stations upon completion of this project and Project ID #F-12136-21) | 11/1/2022 | 1/20/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Mecklenburg | F-012279-22 | Atrium Health Ballantyne Emergency Department | 220728 | HOSPITAL | Cost overrun for Project ID #F-12088-21 (develop a satellite ED) | 11/1/2022 | 1/18/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Pender | O-012276-22 | Valleygate Dental Surgery Center Coast | 220727 | ASC | Develop a new ASC by relocating no more than one OR from Valleygate Dental Surgery Center of Fayetteville with one procedure room | 11/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012248-22 | KM Surgery Center | 220571 | ASC | Develop a multi-specialty ASF with no more than one OR pursuant to the 2022 SMFP with two procedure rooms upon project completion | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012250-22 | Wake Endoscopy Center-Holly Springs | 220577 | ASC | Develop a new ASF with no more than two GI endoscopy rooms | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012252-22 | Oakview ASC, LLC | 220579 | ASC | Develop a single-specialty ophthalmic ASF with no more than one OR pursuant to the need determination in the 2022 SMFP with one procedure room | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012253-22 | Triangle Vascular Care | 220580 | ASC | Develop a ASF with no more than one OR pursuant to the need determination in the 2022 SMFP and two procedure rooms for vascular access procedures | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012261-22 | Duke Health Green Level Ambulatory Surgical Center | 180422 | ASC | Develop no more than two additional operating rooms pursuant to the need determination in the 2022 SMFP which is a change in scope to CON Project ID# J-11557-18 (develop a new ASF with one operating rooms and five procedure rooms) for a total of 3 operating rooms and 3 procedure rooms upon completion of this project and Project ID# J-11557-18 | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012263-22 | Duke Raleigh Hospital | 923421 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than 45 additional acute care beds pursuant to the need determination in the 2022 SMFP for a total of no more than 191 acute care beds upon completion of this project and Project ID# J-12029-21 (Develop a new separately licensed 40-bed hospital [Duke Green Level Hospital] by relocating no more than 40 acute care beds and two shared operating rooms from Duke Raleigh Hospital) | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012264-22 | WakeMed Garner Hospital | 220581 | HOSPITAL | Develop a new hospital with a total of 31 acute care beds and 2 operating rooms by developing no more than 9 new acute care beds and two new operating rooms pursuant to the need determinations in the 2022 SMFP and relocating no more than 22 acute care beds from the WakeMed Raleigh Campus. | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012258-22 | UNC REX Hospital | 953429 | HOSPITAL | Add no more than 36 acute care beds pursuant to the need determination in the 2022 SMFP for a total of no more than 475 acute care beds at UNC REX Hospital upon project completion | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012259-22 | UNC REX Holly Springs Hospital | 070823 | HOSPITAL | Add no more than 9 acute care beds pursuant to the need determination in the 2022 SMFP for a total of no more 59 acute care beds upon project completion | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012260-22 | UNC REX Hospital | 953429 | HOSPITAL | Develop no more than two additional ORs pursuant to the need determination in the 2022 SMFP | 9/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Denied | Findings |
| Wake | J-012291-22 | WakeMed | 943528 | HOSPITAL | Cost overrun for Project ID# J-010165-13 (reconvert 21 NF beds at WakeMed Fuquay-Varina to acute care beds) | 11/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012292-22 | WakeMed North Hospital | 990974 | HOSPITAL | Cost overrun for Project ID# J-010166-13 (reconvert 3 NF beds at WakeMed Fuquay-Varina and 13 NF beds from WakeMed Zebulon-Wendell to acute care beds) | 11/1/2022 | 1/27/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wake | J-012265-22 | WakeMed Behavioral Health Center | 220582 | MHH | Develop a psychiatric hospital by relocating no more than 50 psychiatric inpatient beds from Broughton Hospital pursuant to Policy PSY-1 and developing no more than 100 additional psychiatric inpatient beds for a total of no more than 150 psychiatric inpatient beds upon project completion | 9/1/2022 | 1/18/2023 | Conditional Approval | Findings |
| Wilson | L-012269-22 | Wilson Home Dialysis | 200032 | ESRD | Develop one dialysis station to be used exclusively for home hemodialysis training and support services, which is a Change of Scope for CON Project ID# L-11836-20 | 10/1/2022 | 1/25/2023 | Denied | Findings |